Liquid Eyeliner # 221 Black Noir by Almay for Women - 0.1 oz Eyeliner

I haven't used this liner in a few years because it didn't seem the same. I thought it was just me but after reading these reviews I know I was right Almay did change the formula. What I don't understand all these folks are complaining wanting the old formula back but ALMAY isn't listening to Us. Obviously we know what we are talking about so why won't Almay listen and bring it back. Most stores have even stopped selling it. Just like the saying goes "the customer is always right" so do yourself a favor and listen to your fans and customers. Bring OLD Formula back!!

for over 20 years now I have been using the Precise Black Liquid Eyeliner. I purchase one every month. Over the past few months since the bottle has changed and the name has also changed just to BLACK, it is horrible. it is not the same thing that it used to be. The tip of the applicator gets stringy after only 1 use, the eyeliner itself has started cracking before it is even applied. Can ALMAY please go back to the original bottle and consistency of the first product please.

I’ve been using this product for over 10 years as well. I noticed they changed the design and was a little suspicious. My beloved white handle liquid eyeliner changed packaging and I was scared. After using the new product (changed packaging) I came here to see if anyone was having the same issues as I was. And yep, seems like they did not only change the packaging but the formula is completely different. It gets super chunky, cracks, and I constantly have to fix the tip against the rim of the bottle. I don’t know why companies insist on changing something that is so loved. The old formula worked better. Likely to reduce cost which is unfortunate. I’ll be switching to another brand such as NYX as I’ve heard great things are their liner but I am NOT happy about it. I wish you guys would bring it back. Don’t fix something if it ain’t broken.