Skip to main contentSkip to footer

Customer Reviews

HP 58A (CF258A) Black Original Toner Cartridge

Ratings

4.6

Average rating based on 494 reviews

Rating Breakdown

407 reviewers rated this product 5 stars.

45 reviewers rated this product 4 stars.

11 reviewers rated this product 3 stars.

5 reviewers rated this product 2 stars.

26 reviewers rated this product 1 stars.

Write Your Review

Reviewer Recommendation

95%

Of the 241 reviewers who responded, 228 would recommend this product.

Key Considerations

Averages based on how reviewers feel this product performs.

Quality:
Value:
Ease of Use:

What customers are saying

The HP toner cartridges are described as high-quality, long-lasting, and easy to use. Customers appreciate the cartridges' ability to produce crisp, vibrant prints. While some find the toner to be a bit pricey compared to third-party options, most feel the quality justifies the cost. Overall, the toner cartridges are considered a reliable and satisfactory product that meets the printing needs of a wide range of users.

This summary is generated by AI using customer reviews from multiple languages and translated into English.

Sort

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    HP 58A Laser Toner Cartridge

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - September 14, 2025

    Substitutes for the highly-priced HP 58A may not work even if advertised to include “the chip” which locks the 58A into the HP network. On the other hand, for the everyday household casual user, the 58A seems to last forever, well beyond its low toner earnings, so it’s extremely high price and stocked rarity in the marketplace could be justified if we were assured replacement were totally new and not recycled out of HP’s prepaid used cartridge return program.

    Review originally posted on hp.com


  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    HP LaserJet Ink Toner

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - January 28, 2021

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] HP LaserJet Ink Toner cartridge is very easy to install and the package includes a postage free label to recycle your empty toner cartridge. Don't settle for a knock-off ink toner cartridge. HP is pricey, but stands behind their brand. That's more one can say about companies that sell compatible, but cheaper toner cartridges that don't quite match up to the quality of a genuine HP toner cartridge.

    Review originally posted on bestbuy.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.
    Quality:
    Value:
    Ease of Use:

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    Makes lots of copies

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - July 19, 2020

    Buyers... we bought a new HP all in one printer. The store didn't have a cartridge that it needed. So... we went on line to purchase an extra cartridge & guess what we discovered??? The laser printer NOW has to have a cartridge with a computer chip. What does that mean. You are forced to Purchase a HP cartridge because no cheaper place has them.

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    HP Laser Jet Pro MFP M428fdw

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - January 24, 2021

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I bought this printer couple weeks ago for my in-home office along with a additional 550 page tray. It was easy to set up, prints quick and easy to use. I originally bought a Canon, it was difficult to set up was having problems with it printing scanning etc. within two weeks of purchasing the Canon I returned it and bought an HP - LOVE IT!!

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    Jetprinter ink cartridge

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - September 23, 2025

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I purchased a printer cartridge at Best Buy and my experience was positive. The online purchase process was very simple, and the pickup time at the store was quick and punctual. It was very easy to locate and collect the product. The only downside is that the price is not as competitive compared to other options available in the market.

    Review originally posted on bestbuy.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.
    Quality:
    Value:
    Ease of Use:

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    Excellent high yield toner

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - July 18, 2021

    This is the best high yield toner you can get for your printer. Sure, it's more expensive than aftermarket or third party toner but in the end you end up getting what you pay for and this high yield toner cartridge proves to be worth the money. You will get approximately 10,000 pages from this cartridge.

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    Workhorse

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - July 10, 2020

    this is my third HP printer and so far it is doing everything asked of it, which us alot. Compact. Not the quickest, not the slowest, but reliable and able to handle a large volume. I have had other brands, but after 12 years of running a small business the HP is always the brand I go back to.

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  • Customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars

    Superb machine, with one caveat

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - August 23, 2020

    Speed and functionality are from my perspective unbeatable. Less laudable is incompatibility of toner cartridges for this machine's predecessor , the 426, with the 428. HP, will you detail why outside of obvious financial motive this machine cannot accept cartridges purchased for the 426 ?

    Review originally posted on hp.com


  • Customer rating: 4 out of 5 stars

    set up

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - June 22, 2020

    I had an awful time trying to get it set up, and trying to get a "real" person to help me. I would never have figured it out. Now, it does pretty well, but still having problems with it wanting to kick tray 1 back to modifying the letter size paper in it. Other than that, it is nice.

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.

  • Customer rating: 5 out of 5 stars

    Best ink cartridge because of great quality ink

    Verified BuyerReviewed by - January 12, 2020

    [This review was collected as part of a promotion.] I have always bought HP products because they make the very best printers. HP is a quality brand that you can take to the bank. HP has always performed excellent for me as well as my family. Simply put HP products are the best your money can buy. I will only buy HP products!

    Review originally posted on hp.com

    Yes, I would recommend this to a friend.