Best Simple Toaster

Finding the perfect simple toaster can make busy mornings easier and breakfast routines more enjoyable. Our expertly curated list highlights the top-rated toasters, chosen based on real user reviews for... reliability, ease of use, and consistent performance. Whether you’re looking for a straightforward appliance that delivers perfectly golden toast or a compact design to fit any kitchen space, these highly recommended options ensure a hassle-free start to your day. Discover the best simple toasters that combine functionality, style, and customer satisfaction.
Read more

What to look for in a simple toaster

1. Number of Slots

Consider how many slices of bread you typically toast at once. Two-slice toasters are great for smaller households, while four-slice models are ideal for families or frequent entertainers.

2. Browning Settings

Look for a toaster with adjustable browning controls so you can customize the level of crispness to your liking. Some models offer extra settings for bagels or defrosting frozen bread.

3. Ease of Cleaning

A removable crumb tray makes it much easier to clean out crumbs and keep your toaster in top shape. This feature helps prevent burning and keeps your kitchen tidy.

4. Size and Design

Choose a toaster that fits comfortably on your countertop and matches your kitchen decor. Compact designs are perfect for small spaces, while sleek finishes can add a modern touch.
Citrus catapult arrow
  1. 1
    CUISINART Cpt-160C Metal Classic 2-Slice Toaster Best 2 slice toaster

    About this product

    A stainless steel toaster featuring 6 shade settings, wide slots, extra-lift levers, and easy-clean crumb tray.

    A stainless steel toaster featuring 6 shade settings, wide slots, extra-lift levers, and easy-clean crumb tray.

    What customers like

    • Wide slots accommodate various bread sizes
    • Durable and well-constructed
    • Attractive stainless steel design
    • Consistent and even toasting
    • Easy to clean with slide-out crumb tray
    4.3 (1,829 reviews)
    $129.99
    SAVE $20
    Your price for this item is $129.99
  2. 2
    Hamilton Beach Contemporary Toaster - 2-Slice - Black and Stainless Steel Great little Toaster

    About this product

    A sleek black and stainless steel toaster with seven shade settings and self-centring guides for even toasting.

    A sleek black and stainless steel toaster with seven shade settings and self-centring guides for even toasting.

    What customers like

    • Sleek and stylish stainless steel design
    • Easy-to-clean removable crumb tray
    • Even and consistent toasting performance
    • Wide slots accommodate various breads and bagels
    • User-friendly controls and adjustable shade settings
    4.5 (1,017 reviews)
    $34.99 Your price for this item is $34.99
  3. 3
    Bella Pro Toaster - 2-Slice - Stainless Steel - Only at Best Buy Omg I love my toaster looks great with my Insignia appliances I just bought from Best Buy too

    About this product

    A sleek stainless steel toaster with illuminated indicators and customizable settings for perfectly toasted breads and bagels.

    A sleek stainless steel toaster with illuminated indicators and customizable settings for perfectly toasted breads and bagels.

    What customers like

    • Sleek and stylish stainless steel design
    • Versatile settings for bagels and gluten-free breads
    • Easy to use and clean with removable crumb tray
    • Compact size with convenient cord storage
    • Even and quick toasting performance
    4.6 (405 reviews)
    $39.99
    SAVE $70
    Your price for this item is $39.99
  4. 4
    Black & Decker Toaster - 4-Slice Great features!

    About this product

    A sleek stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and user-friendly controls for versatile toasting.

    A sleek stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and user-friendly controls for versatile toasting.

    What customers like

    • Sleek stainless steel design
    • Consistent and even toasting for four slices at once
    • Easy to use and clean with removable crumb trays
    • Extra-wide slots fit bagels and thick slices
    • Multiple toasting options including bagel and frozen settings
    4.7 (77 reviews)
    $57.98
    SAVE $7
    Your price for this item is $57.98
  5. 5
    Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide Slot Toaster - 2-Slice - Brushed Stainless Steel Great features with sort of retro look

    About this product

    A brushed stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and seven shade settings for customized toasting.

    A brushed stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and seven shade settings for customized toasting.

    What customers like

    • Easy to clean with removable crumb tray
    • Simple controls and easy to use
    • Extra-wide slots fit bagels and thick breads
    • Compact and space-saving design
    • Consistent and even toasting performance
    4.5 (75 reviews)
    $39.99 Your price for this item is $39.99
  6. 6
    WILLOW 2 Slice Toaster- In Black Great design and compact size

    About this product

    A sleek black toaster with six shade settings, high-lift toast boost, and easy-clean crumb tray.

    A sleek black toaster with six shade settings, high-lift toast boost, and easy-clean crumb tray.

    What customers like

    • Easy to clean with removable crumb tray
    • Compact and sleek design
    • Even toasting and consistent results
    • Accommodates various breads and thick slices
    • Easy to use with simple controls
    5.0 (61 reviews)
    $59.99 Your price for this item is $59.99
  7. 7
    KITCHENAID 4-Slice Toaster With Manual High-Lift Lever, Contour Silver, Kmt4115Cu Best Toaster ever

    About this product

    A contour silver toaster with four extra-wide slots and dual independent controls for versatile toasting.

    A contour silver toaster with four extra-wide slots and dual independent controls for versatile toasting.

    What customers like

    • Easy to use and clean
    • Durable build quality
    • Wide slots accommodate thick bread
    • Attractive and stylish design
    • Even and consistent toasting
    4.2 (291 reviews)
    $128.53
    SAVE $121
    Your price for this item is $128.53
  8. 8
    Hamilton Beach Extra-Wide Slot Toaster - 2-Slice - Black/Stainless Steel Great toaster for a Great price

    About this product

    A two-slice toaster in black and stainless steel with extra-wide slots and seven shade settings.

    A two-slice toaster in black and stainless steel with extra-wide slots and seven shade settings.

    What customers like

    • Compact and stylish design
    • Removable crumb tray for easy cleaning
    • Extra-wide slots fit bagels and thick breads
    • Easy to use with simple controls
    • Even and consistent toasting performance
    4.5 (152 reviews)
    $44.99 Your price for this item is $44.99
  9. 9
    KitchenAid Toaster - 4-Slice - Stainless Steel - Only at Best Buy I love my new toaster it's very durable and the extra large slots makes it easy to use a variety of bread

    About this product

    A stainless steel four-slice toaster with extra-wide slots and adjustable toasting shades for perfect results.

    A stainless steel four-slice toaster with extra-wide slots and adjustable toasting shades for perfect results.

    What customers like

    • Versatile toasting options and settings
    • Stylish and modern design
    • Easy to clean with removable crumb trays
    • Durable and well-built construction
    • Extra-wide slots fit bagels and large bread
    4.8 (119 reviews)
    $219.99 Your price for this item is $219.99
  10. 10
    KitchenAid Toaster - 2-Slice - Stainless Steel - Only at Best Buy Great Buy!

    About this product

    A stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and adjustable browning for perfectly toasted bread every time.

    A stainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots and adjustable browning for perfectly toasted bread every time.

    What customers like

    • Sleek and modern design
    • Multiple adjustable toasting settings
    • Easy to clean and maintain
    • Extra-wide slots fit various breads
    • Consistent and even toasting
    4.5 (68 reviews)
    $129.99
    SAVE $60
    Your price for this item is $129.99

FAQ

What features should I look for in a simple toaster? + -

When choosing a simple toaster, consider features like the number of browning settings, ease of use, removable crumb trays for easy cleaning, and wide slots to accommodate different types of bread.

Are simple toasters easy to clean? + -

Yes, most simple toasters are designed with removable crumb trays and smooth surfaces, making them quick and easy to clean after use.

Can a basic toaster handle different types of bread? + -

Many simple toasters have wide slots that can fit various bread types, including bagels, English muffins, and thicker artisan slices.

How long does it take for a simple toaster to toast bread? + -

The time it takes varies by model and browning setting, but most simple toasters can toast bread in about 2-4 minutes.

Do simple toasters come with any special functions? + -

While basic models focus on straightforward operation, many still offer useful functions like cancel buttons or reheat and defrost settings for added convenience.

Related Pages

  • Front_Zoom
    Most Reliable Toaster

    "I love my new toaster it's very durable and the extra large slots makes it easy to use a variety of bread"

  • Front_Zoom
    Energy Efficient Toaster

    "The air fryer portion works great for making french fries and it is the best way to cook pizza"

  • Front_Zoom
    Slice Toaster

    "Love the extra wide slots that even the larger bagels fit and are toasted just right using the bagel"

  • Front_Zoom
    Toaster Oven Under $100

    "This little guy is great for small spaces. Collage kids will love this toaster"

Some products may be subject to Environmental Handling Fees (EHF) depending on your province. Learn more about EHFs.