Best Mascaras

When it comes to finding the perfect mascara, the options can be overwhelming. From volumizing to lengthening, waterproof to smudge-proof, there are countless choices available. That's why we've curated... a list of the best mascaras based on user review ratings, so you can easily discover the top performers in the market. Whether you're seeking a dramatic look for a night out or a natural enhancement for everyday wear, our ranking showcases the most beloved mascaras that have earned the trust and praise of beauty enthusiasts. Say goodbye to clumps, flakes, and smudges, and say hello to luscious lashes with our carefully curated selection of top-rated mascaras.
Read more

What to look for in the best mascaras

1. Brush Type

The type of brush can greatly affect the result. Thicker brushes tend to add volume, while thinner, comb-like brushes are great for separation and length.

2. Formula

Mascaras come in different formulas, such as waterproof, smudge-proof, or fiber-based for extra length. Choose one that suits your lifestyle and preferences.

3. Ingredients

Look out for ingredients that can nourish your lashes like biotin, keratin, or natural oils.

4. Ease of Removal

Some mascaras can be tough to remove, leading to potential lash loss. Consider a mascara that is long-lasting but also easy to take off at the end of the day.
Citrus catapult arrow
  1. 1
    SISLEY So Curl Curling Fortifying Mascara - 03 Deep By for Women - 0.33 OZ Mascara In Blue This for me is the best mascara

    About this product

    A blue mascara that thickens and lengthens lashes with peptides, arginines, and polymers.

    A blue mascara that thickens and lengthens lashes with peptides, arginines, and polymers.

    5.0 (8 reviews)
    $324.00 Your price for this item is $324
  2. 2
    GUERLAIN Mad Eyes Mascara - # 01 Mad 8.5Ml/0.28OZ In Black

    About this product

    A fragrant volumizing mascara with a soft fiber brush for spectacular lash volume in black.

    A fragrant volumizing mascara with a soft fiber brush for spectacular lash volume in black.

    What customers like

    • Effective volumizing and lengthening
    • Non-clumping formula
    • Suitable for contact lens wearers
    • Easy to remove
    • Long-lasting wear
    4.5 (80 reviews)
    $226.50 Your price for this item is $226.50
  3. 3
    E.L.F. COSMETICS E.l.f. Big Mood Mascara Bundle love

    About this product

    A volumizing mascara bundle that delivers bold, dramatic lashes for a striking eye look.

    A volumizing mascara bundle that delivers bold, dramatic lashes for a striking eye look.

    What customers like

    • Easy to remove and comfortable to wear
    • Long-lasting and smudge-proof
    • Volumizes and lengthens lashes
    • Smooth, clump-free application
    • Affordable price and quality packaging
    4.2 (4,230 reviews)
    $41.26 Your price for this item is $41.26
  4. 4
    BENEFIT They're Real Beyond Mascara - 8.5G/0.3OZ In Black

    About this product

    A lengthening black mascara that delivers dramatic volume and definition for bold, eye-catching lashes.

    A lengthening black mascara that delivers dramatic volume and definition for bold, eye-catching lashes.

    What customers like

    • Long-lasting and non-flaking
    • Dramatic volume and length
    • Intense black color
    • Easy and precise application
    • Unique brush design
    4.1 (778 reviews)
    $198.00 Your price for this item is $198
  5. 5
    RIMMEL LONDON Scandaleyes Retro Glam Waterproof Mascara - Waterproof - In Black

    About this product

    A waterproof black mascara that delivers bold, retro-inspired volume for dramatic eye looks.

    A waterproof black mascara that delivers bold, retro-inspired volume for dramatic eye looks.

    What customers like

    • No clumping and separates lashes
    • Affordable and good value
    • Long-lasting and waterproof
    • Easy to apply and beginner-friendly
    • Adds volume and length
    4.1 (130 reviews)
    $30.09 Your price for this item is $30.09
  6. 6
    BENEFIT Badgal Bang Volumizing Mascara - # Intense Pitch 8.5G/0.3OZ In Black

    About this product

    A pitch black volumizing mascara that delivers dramatic lift and fullness to your lashes.

    A pitch black volumizing mascara that delivers dramatic lift and fullness to your lashes.

    What customers like

    • No clumping or flaking
    • Lightweight and comfortable
    • Adds noticeable volume and length
    • Long-lasting wear
    • Easy and precise application
    3.8 (315 reviews)
    $33.99 Your price for this item is $33.99
  7. 7
    GIVENCHY Volume Disturbia Mascara - # 01 Disturbia - 8G/0.28OZ In Black

    About this product

    A powerful volumizing mascara with a smooth-gliding, clump-free formula for intense black lashes.

    A powerful volumizing mascara with a smooth-gliding, clump-free formula for intense black lashes.

    What customers like

    • Volumizing effect
    • No clumping
    • Beautiful packaging
    • Intense black color
    • Long-lasting effect
    4.9 (112 reviews)
    $199.50 Your price for this item is $199.50
  8. 8
    SHISEIDO Controlledchaos Mascaraink - # 01 Pulse 11.5Ml/0.32OZ In Black So far, it's the best mascara I ever used

    About this product

    A weightless black mascara delivering volumized, clump-free lashes with a smudge-resistant, flexible formula.

    A weightless black mascara delivering volumized, clump-free lashes with a smudge-resistant, flexible formula.

    What customers like

    • Deep, vibrant color with true black pigmentation
    • Clump-free and smudge-resistant formula
    • Volumizes and lengthens lashes
    • Easy and precise application with quality brush
    • Long-lasting wear and easy removal
    4.4 (84 reviews)
    $202.50 Your price for this item is $202.50
  9. 9
    STILA Magnum Xxx Mascara - Intense By for Women - 0.40 OZ Mascara In Black

    About this product

    A lightweight, non-clumping black mascara with exceptional curl retention and lash hold.

    A lightweight, non-clumping black mascara with exceptional curl retention and lash hold.

    4.7 (9 reviews)
    $45.96 Your price for this item is $45.96
  10. 10
    KANEBO Sensai Lash Lengthener 38°C Mascara -#black 10Ml

    About this product

    A high-performance black mascara that lengthens and separates lashes with innovative nylon fiber.

    A high-performance black mascara that lengthens and separates lashes with innovative nylon fiber.

    5.0 (3 reviews)
    $222.00 Your price for this item is $222

FAQ

What are the different types of mascara available? + -

There are several types of mascara, including volumizing, lengthening, curling, waterproof, and fiber mascaras. Each type is designed to enhance your lashes in different ways, so you can choose based on your desired look.

How do I choose the right mascara for my lashes? + -

To choose the right mascara, consider your lash type and desired effect. If you have short lashes, a lengthening mascara might be best. For thin lashes, a volumizing formula can add fullness. Waterproof options are great for long-lasting wear.

How often should I replace my mascara? + -

It's recommended to replace your mascara every three months. This helps prevent bacteria buildup and ensures optimal performance of the product.

Can I use mascara if I wear contact lenses? + -

Yes, you can use mascara if you wear contact lenses. Look for formulas that are ophthalmologist-tested and hypoallergenic to minimize any potential irritation.

What is the best way to apply mascara for maximum effect? + -

For maximum effect, start by curling your lashes with an eyelash curler. Then, apply mascara from the base of your lashes to the tips using a zigzag motion to ensure even coverage and separation. Apply multiple coats for added volume and length.

Related Pages

Some products may be subject to Environmental Handling Fees (EHF) depending on your province. Learn more about EHFs.