Best Horror Games on PS5

Turn down the lights and get ready for chilling adventures with the best horror games, ranked by user review ratings. From tense survival challenges to unsettling psychological stories, this selection offers plenty of ways to test your nerves. Explore player favourites and find your next fright, whether you enjoy unravelling dark mysteries, managing scarce supplies, or facing terrifying foes.

Read More

What to look for in the best horror games on PS5

1. Horror Style

Survival horror often builds tension through scarce supplies, while psychological horror relies on unsettling stories and atmosphere. Consider whether you prefer slow-building dread, sudden scares, or action-packed encounters.

2. Gameplay and Difficulty

Some horror games focus on combat, while others ask you to hide, solve puzzles, or escape without fighting. Check for difficulty settings and accessibility options that let you tailor the challenge to your comfort level.

3. PS5 Features and Compatibility

Confirm that you’re choosing the PS5 version and check whether it supports features such as haptic feedback, adaptive triggers, or 3D audio. If you’re buying a physical copy, make sure your PS5 has a compatible disc drive.

4. Story Length and Replay Value

Choose between a shorter, focused story and a longer adventure with more areas to explore. Multiple endings, unlockable modes, and optional challenges can give you reasons to return after the first playthrough.
  1. 1

    GEARBOX PUBLISHING Hello Neighbor 2 - Deluxe Edition [Playstation 5]

    About this product

    An immersive family-friendly horror game with three DLC packs, set in the mysterious town of Raven Brooks.

    (2)
    $103.49 Your price for this item is $103.49
  2. 2

    GS2 GAMES Burnhouse Lane [Playstation 5]

    About this product

    A narrative-driven horror adventure where you face tough choices, survival challenges, and emotional storytelling.

    (1)
    $28.74 Your price for this item is $28.74
  3. 3

    GAME SOLUTIONS 2 Remorse The List (Ps5)

    About this product

    A psychological horror game for PS5 featuring immersive gameplay and intense, atmospheric storytelling.

    (1)
    $34.49 Your price for this item is $34.49
  4. 4

    Resident Evil Requiem (PS5)

    About this product

    A next-generation survival horror experience featuring lifelike visuals, intense realism, and immersive gameplay.

    What customers like

    • Balanced mix of horror and action
    • Immersive and atmospheric gameplay
    • Engaging and gripping story
    • Smooth performance and responsive controls
    • Stunning graphics and visual effects
    (448)
    $79.99 Your price for this item is $79.99
  5. 5

    Silent Hill 2 (PS5)

    About this product

    A chilling horror adventure reimagined with modern graphics and classic characters for PlayStation 5.

    What customers like

    • Immersive sound design and soundtrack
    • Faithful remake honoring the original classic
    • Engaging storytelling and psychological depth
    • Atmospheric and chilling horror experience
    • Stunning modern graphics and visuals
    (469)
    $39.99 Your price for this item is $39.99
  6. 6

    MAXIMUM GAMES Ad Infinitum [Playstation 5]

    About this product

    A psychological horror game where you confront nightmarish creatures and haunting memories of World War I.

    (5)
    $34.49 Your price for this item is $34.49
  7. 7

    GAME SOLUTIONS 2 Choo-Choo Charles (Ps5)

    About this product

    A thrilling PlayStation 5 adventure game featuring suspenseful gameplay and immersive graphics.

    (9)
    $34.49 Your price for this item is $34.49
  8. 8

    Silent Hill f Day One Edition (PS5)

    About this product

    A psychological horror adventure set in 1960s Japan, featuring puzzles and terrifying monsters on PS5.

    What customers like

    • Stunning graphics and visuals
    • Challenging and enjoyable gameplay
    • Faithful return to psychological horror roots
    • Engaging and gripping story
    • Atmospheric and immersive experience
    (216)
    $54.99 Your price for this item is $54.99
  9. 9

    Silent Hill Townfall: Day One Edition (PS5)

    About this product

    A first-person psychological horror adventure on PS5 with exploration, evasion, survival, and chilling Scottish atmosphere.

    (3)
    $69.99 Your price for this item is $69.99
  10. 10

    Hell is Us (PS5)

    About this product

    An intense third-person action-adventure where you battle supernatural foes and uncover secrets in a war-torn world.

    (18)
    $67.98 Your price for this item is $67.98

Suspense that suits your pace and play style

The best horror games make familiar spaces feel unsettling: an empty hallway, a rain-streaked window, a door that was definitely closed a moment ago. The Best Horror Games on PS5 collection brings that sense of suspense to players who enjoy a little tension with their downtime, whether that means unravelling a mystery or finding a way through an unfamiliar place with limited supplies. Choosing the right game starts with the kind of experience you enjoy. Survival-focused games often make every item and inventory slot matter, while action-oriented horror puts more emphasis on movement, timing, and quick decisions. Story-driven adventures can offer a slower pace, with clues, conversations, and exploration doing much of the work. If your favourite part of a scary evening is the anticipation rather than the shock, look for descriptions that emphasize atmosphere, puzzles, and psychological suspense over frequent combat.

How you like to play matters just as much as what scares you. A carefully paced single-player game suits an evening when you can settle in, follow the story, and notice the small details tucked into each room. For shorter sessions, convenient save points, clear objectives, and adjustable difficulty can make it easier to step away without losing hard-earned progress. Supported controller features can add texture to an encounter through subtle vibrations or trigger resistance, while positional audio may help you place a creaking floorboard or distant footstep. These features vary by game, so check the listing rather than assuming every title uses them in the same way. Headphones can make quiet details easier to hear, though speaker audio is still a practical choice when you want to stay aware of the room around you. Subtitle options, readable text, brightness controls, and motion settings are also worth checking, especially if dark scenes or fast camera movement can make play uncomfortable.

Horror games can be a thoughtful gift for someone who loves eerie fiction, escape-room puzzles, or a mystery that keeps them guessing, but matching their comfort level is more useful than simply choosing the most intense option. Check the age rating and content descriptors, along with details about jump scares, disturbing imagery, and available accessibility settings. If the recipient prefers playing with friends, confirm whether multiplayer is included, whether it supports local or online play, and whether an additional subscription is required. Format deserves a close look, too: a physical disc needs a compatible disc drive, while a digital game requires enough storage space for the download and any updates. Some games also need an internet connection for certain features. Getting these practical details right leaves more room for the enjoyable part: dimming the lights, keeping a favourite snack within reach, and deciding whether to open that suspicious door before calling it a night.

Read More

FAQ

Some products may be subject to Environmental Handling Fees (EHF) depending on your province. Learn more about EHFs.